Seven Ways to Cut Costs on Your Next Five Guys Order

Look, we all know Five Guys makes incredible burgers. That’s not up for debate. But let’s be real: it’s expensive. Dropping twenty bucks on a burger, fries, and a drink is basically the norm now. It stings a little every time. But here’s the thing—there are ways to order smarter. Real strategies that actually work. Some are simple, some are a little creative, but all of them can save you serious money. Here’s what you need to know.

Know That Five Guys Is the Most Expensive Burger Chain – and Plan Accordingly

This last one isn’t a hack. It’s just perspective. Five Guys was ranked the most expensive burger chain in a 2024 report. The average meal—burger, fries, drink—hit $20.84 in 2024, up 14% from two years earlier. No senior discounts, no student discounts, no loyalty programs. The only leverage you have is ordering smarter. Use every free topping, share fries, try the sandwich alternatives, attempt the double-bun trick. These aren’t shortcuts. They’re just good strategy for a chain that gives you the tools to spend less without eating less.

Load Up on the 15 Free Toppings – Every Single Time

This is the thing new visitors always miss. You can pile on toppings without paying a cent more. Fifteen of them. Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, grilled mushrooms, jalapeños, grilled onions, A1 sauce—you can add all of them if you want. No extra charge. That’s over 250,000 possible burger combinations. You’re basically getting a fully loaded, custom burger at the same price as a plain one. Always take advantage. It’s like free upgrades on a flight, but way more satisfying.peppers, and you’ve transformed a basic patty into something seriously special – at no added cost.

Skip the Fancy Burger and Try the Grilled Cheese Patty Melt Hack

This might be the most underrated hack on the list. Order a grilled cheese sandwich and add a burger patty. It costs less than a cheeseburger but gives you the same core experience. A regular bacon cheeseburger runs nearly $14. A grilled cheese with bacon and a patty? About $7.19. The idea started on Reddit, blew up on TikTok, and for good reason. You get buttery toasted bread, melted cheese, and a hot patty. Smart ordering at its finest.

Order the Regular Burger and Ask for an Extra Bun – Walk Away With Two

This one sounds too good to be true, but it’s legit. Five Guys regular burgers come with two patties. Their “little” burgers have one. So here’s the move: order a regular burger, ask for an extra bun, and get your toppings on the side. Boom—two burgers for the price of one. You’re paying about $9.89 for two instead of roughly $15.38 for two little burgers. Not every location will hand over an extra bun for free, so be polite and don’t push it. But when it works? That’s a serious win.

Share a Regular Order of Fries – Seriously, One Is Enough

Five Guys fries are legendary, and the portions are genuinely absurd. They scoop fries into the bag until it’s overflowing. A regular size is easily enough for two or three people. This isn’t an exaggeration. If you’re with someone, order one regular and split it. You’ll have plenty, and you’ll save whatever you would’ve spent on a second order. Plus, they’re fresh-cut, soaked in water, and fried in peanut oil. High-quality fries, massive portion, half the cost.

Choose the Veggie Sandwich for a Budget-Friendly, Topping-Loaded Meal

Most people don’t even know this exists. Five Guys has a veggie sandwich that comes with all the same toppings as a burger—grilled onions, mushrooms, green peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, whatever you want—for significantly less money. Add jalapeños and A1 sauce, and you’ve got a genuinely satisfying meal for around five to eight bucks, depending on location. You’re getting the same fresh ingredients, same kitchen, same care, just without the beef patty markup. For anyone watching their budget, this is a smart move.

Snack on the Free Peanuts While You Wait – It’s Built Into the Experience

The peanuts aren’t just there for decoration. They’re a legit part of the experience, and you’re technically paying for them whether you eat them or not. So eat them. Munching while you wait takes the edge off your hunger, which means you might not need to order as much food overall. It started as a way to keep customers occupied during the cook time, and it stuck because it works. Fill up a little before the burger arrives. Simple logic, bigger savings.